Alaska Supreme Court July 29, 2005, No. S-11084 (Johnson v. Hughes Thorsness Powell Huddleston & Bauman LLC)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-07-2005

OPINION

FABE, Justice.

I. INTRODUCTION

Maynard Johnson moved to reopen probate proceedings for his father's estate because he believed the legal fees incurred during the closing of the estate were excessive. The superior court denied his motion and Maynard Johnson appealed. We remanded the case to the superior court to determine the reasonableness of professional fees charged to the estate. The probate master held an evidentiary hearing and concluded that the legal fees were reasonable, and the superior court approved the findings. Maynard Johnson appeals that determination and several related matters. Because we conclude that the appellee did not meet its burden of proving the reasonableness of all of the legal fees charged to the estate, we reverse in part the superior court's order.

II. FACTS AND PROCEEDINGS

A. Facts

Clifford M. Johnson died in 1988. His sister, Evva Betts, was appointed as the personal representative for his estate under his will. The will bequeathed $5,000 to Naney Wharton and the residue of the estate to Clifford Johnson's son, Maynard Johnson. Maynard Johnson is the appellant in this case.

In 1984 attorneys for the personal representative submitted an inventory of the es*427tate assets. The total assets were valued at $682,798. The principal assets in the estate were a partnership in a drilling company, a bar and store in South Naknek, several parcels of land, and $70,000 in accounts receivable from the store.1

The estate debts totaled $185,746.2 The debts consisted of a $100,821.95 obligation to Humana Hospital for expenses associated with Clifford Johnson's illness, a bank note in the amount of $17,961.82, federal taxes in the amount of $41,695, promissory notes to private parties, trade accounts relating to the bar and store, and additional medical bills.

Following his father's death, Johnson continued to operate the bar and store.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.