Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York November 10, 2005 (Robinson v. Scafidi)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-11-2005

Carpinello, J.

Appeal from an order of the Supreme Court (Benza, J.), entered October 4, 2004 in Albany County, which, inter alia, granted defendant Joseph Van Alphen’s motion for summary judgment dismissing the complaint against him.

Between August 1998 and October 1999, plaintiff lived in three different residential buildings in the City of Albany with her young son. After the child registered an elevated blood lead level at his two-year-old doctor’s appointment in October 1999, an investigation by the Albany County Department of Health revealed that all three of these apartments had areas containing lead paint. This action was filed against each landlord, as well as two municipal entities, seeking damages for the child’s lead poisoning injuries. The sole issue before us on appeal is the *828propriety of summary judgment to defendant Joseph Van Alphen. Van Alphen owned the apartment in which plaintiff resided for 5Vs months between mid-February 1999 and July 31, 1999.* 1 Finding that Supreme Court properly granted summary judgment to Van Alphen, we now affirm.

Although not really disputed, we begin by finding that Van Alphen made a prima facie showing of his entitlement to summary judgment as a matter of law thus obligating plaintiff, under the five prongs outlined in Chapman v Silber (97 NY2d 9, 15 [2001]), to raise a triable issue of fact.2 **5Here, plaintiff failed to satisfy all five prongs in that she was unable to show that Van Alphen was aware that paint was peeling on the premises during her tenancy (i.e., the third Chapman prong). According to plaintiff, when she moved into the apartment in mid-February 1999, it was in “excellent” condition. Indeed, prior to her entry, the entire apartment, with the exception of the bathroom, had been repainted.

Plaintiff also testified that she never observed any chipping or peeling paint anywhere inside the apartment during her tenancy (compare Wynn v T.R.I.P. Redevelopment Assoc., 296 AD2d 176 [2002]).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.