New York Supreme Court May 5, 2005 (200 East 27th LLC v. Schiffmiller-Nachshen)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-05-2005

*346OPINION OF THE COURT

Edward H. Lehner, J.

The prime issue raised on this motion by defendants pursuant to CPLR 3211 (a) (1) and (7) to dismiss the complaint is whether the plaintiff landlord may recover money damages in an action based on defendants’ alleged fraud in failing to advise their landlord that the apartment they leased was not their primary residence.

Defendants are the tenants of apartment 9C at 201 East 25th Street. The building is operated as a cooperative, and plaintiff is the holder of the unsold shares applicable to the apartment. Defendants’ occupancy is subject to the Rent Stabilization Law. Their lease, entered into in 2002, expired on September 30, 2004. Pursuant to said law, on June 25, 2004 plaintiff tendered defendants a proposed renewal lease, which defendants originally stated they did not receive but, after intervention of the State Division of Housing and Community Renewal, was eventually signed and returned to plaintiff on September 6, 2004.

In the complaint, plaintiff alleges that the apartment is not defendants’ primary residence and that defendant Schiffmiller-Nachshen: in a telephone conversation in July 2004 “represented that she primarily resided in the Apartment” (11 15); “with fraudulent intent and bad faith, maintains her primary residence at an abode other than the subject premises” (1i 23); and “concealed her true primary residence in order to fraudulently maintain possession of the Apartment that is currently valued at a much higher value than it is under its present rent stabilized status” (11 24). As a consequence of the foregoing, plaintiff seeks damages of $750,000 as the fair market value of the apartment, $2,500,000 in punitive damages, and $97,433.04 as additional rental that plaintiff could have procured through September 30, 2006, the expiration date of the renewal lease.

In her opposing affidavit, Mrs.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.