Louisiana Court of Appeal September 21, 2005, No. 40,151-CA (Short v. Anders)
Also known as
United States · · · 21-09-2005
J^DREW, J.
Plaintiff, Wendell Short, and defendant, Helen Anders, entered into a verbal contract concerning the clearing of land owned by Mrs. Anders and her husband. The property was located near Calhoun, Louisiana. There is no dispute that the price for the work to be done on the 4tk- to 5-acre tract of rural land was $1,500.00. However, the parties later disagreed on whether the work was only to include “bushhogging,” or was also to include bulldozing. Finding the former, the trial court ruled in favor of Short. We affirm.
FACTS
According to Short, the verbal agreement was only for bushhogging, which Short performed on two separate occasions. He testified that on the first occasion he spent approximately “six hours or better,” and on the second occasion he spent approximately five and a half hours. Short further testified that after the first occasion, he was paid $750.00, and was told that the work wasn’t done properly. He then returned to do additional work, but was never paid the $750.00 balance.
Short stated that the land was hilly and one hill on the property was “kind of dangerous,” having stumps. His tractor became stuck on one stump. He also stated that the tractor got stuck in some holes on the property and that he hired a “sub” to help him with the work. James Shell testified that he went with Short on the first occasion and that the property was “in bad shape.” Shell described brush, most of which was “like six feet tall grass.” He also described “three feet holes” in the land where the tractor could not run. Shell testified that he actually ran the tractor off into one of 12the holes. However, Shell did not know anything about the agreement between Wendell Short and Helen Anders.
Short’s second witness at trial was Ben Owens, who accompanied Short on his second trip to work on the property. Owens testified that he did most of the walking around, picking up sticks and big limbs to avoid tearing up the “bushhog.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit