Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit September 9, 2005, 04-1642 (Lexington Insurance Company v. Western Pennsylvania Hospital)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-09-2005
423 F.3d 318 LEXINGTON INSURANCE COMPANY v. WESTERN PENNSYLVANIA HOSPITAL; Elizabeth Lieb; Harry Lieb, h/w, Parents, and Natural Guardians of Kathryn Lieb, a Minor Western Pennsylvania Hospital, Appellant. No. 04-1642. United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit. Argued June 7, 2005. Filed September 9, 2005. COPYRIGHT MATERIAL OMITTED Thomas E. Birsic (Argued), Charles E. McChesney II, Kirkpatrick & Lockhart LLP, Pittsburgh, PA, for Appellant. Edward B. Wood, Wood Group, P.C., Pittsburgh, PA, for Appellant. Stephen A. Cozen (Argued), Deborah M. Minkoff, Nancy Stuart Portney, Cozen O'Connor, Philadelphia, PA, for Appellee. Before FUENTES, VAN ANTWERPEN, and BECKER, Circuit Judges. BECKER, Circuit Judge. 1 Lexington Insurance Company ("Lexington") sought a declaratory judgment in the District Court that it is not liable for payment of a medical malpractice claim against its insured, Western Pennsylvania Hospital ("West Penn"), because West Penn notified Lexington of the claim more than a year and a half after the policy period ended. The District Court found for Lexington, determining that the claim was governed by Lexington's excess coverage provision created by Endorsement # 007 of the policy, which provides follow-form, claims-made coverage; and that the policy required West Penn to notify Lexington of any claims before the close of the policy period, which it failed to do. 2 West Penn relies on Endorsement # 001, which provided that the Lexington policy would apply immediately over the coverage limit of the Pennsylvania CAT Fund (described infra p.4). West Penn contends that Endorsement # 007 and Endorsement # 001 are mutually exclusive, such that, where, as here, the CAT Fund took responsibility for paying the underlying claim, the notice provisions contained in Lexington's occurrence policy—which permits a more flexible time limit for reporting claims than under Endorsement # 007—should apply instead of Endorsement # 007's notice provisions.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit