Massachusetts Superior Court October 18, 2005, No. 9900467B (Massachusetts Electric Co. v. Commercial Union Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-10-2005

Kern, Leila R., J.

INTRODUCTION

In Phase I of this litigation, the plaintiff utility companies seek to obtain excess liability coverage from the defendant insurers in connection with the cleanup of environmental contamination at the sites of former manufactured gas plants in Lynn, Salem and Malden. This matter is before the court on the defendants’ joint motion for partial summary judgment pursuant to Mass.R.Civ.P. 56 as to the owned property exclusion and the plaintiffs’ cross motion for summary judgment on that issue. For the reasons discussed below, the defendants’ motion is DENIED and the plaintiffs’ cross motion is DENIED.

DISCUSSION

Each of the policies issued to NEES by Certain London Market Insurers, Home Insurance Company, First State Insurance Company and Midland Insurance Company contains an owned property exclusion. There are minor variations in language, but a representative exclusion states: “(t]his Policy shall not apply ... to damages, direct or consequential, or expenses because of injury to or destruction of property owned by the Assured.”

The environmental engineering firm Haley & Aldrich, Inc. is conducting the investigation and remediation of the Lynn site. The Risk Characterization for the Lynn site identified 33 exposure scenarios, and the estimated cost of eliminating these scenarios is $4,354,000. Mass. Electric purchased nine parcels at the Lynn site for $13 million in connection with its remediation efforts. Haley & Aldrich is also conducting the investigation and remediation of the Malden site, which consists of five parcels that are now designated Parcels A, B, C, D and E. The estimated cost of the Malden remediation is $4.95 million. The investigation and remediation of the Salem site is being undertaken by consultants GEI and Hart Crowser. Area 1 of the Salem site consists of the Keyspan property, a location known as 15 Bridge Street, and 6.8 acres of the MEC property at the site. Area 2 of the Salem site consists of the remaining 12.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.