Massachusetts Superior Court October 25, 2005, No. 022191 (Thrifty Financial Services, Inc. v. People's Service Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-10-2005

Connors, Thomas A., J.

The present action commenced when the plaintiff, Thrifty Financial Services, Inc. (“Thrifty”), filed a four-count complaint against defendant Peoples Service Insurance Company (“Peoples”), alleging improper use of and failure to remit return premiums.2 Peoples responded to the claim and asserted a five-count counterclaim against Thrifty.3 In addition, Peoples asserted a third-party claim against the remaining defendants, seeking contribution for or indemnity from Thrifty’s claim. Thrifty now moves this court to grant partial summary judgment as to liability on all counts in the complaint and counterclaim.4

For the reasons that follow, the plaintiffs motion for summary judgment is ALLOWED IN PART, only as to each of the counterclaims brought against it. Thrifty’s motion for summary judgment on its claims against Peoples is DENIED, and pursuant to Rule 56(c), the court ORDERS that summary judgment enter on behalf of the defendant on each of Thrifty’s claims against it.

Background

The present suit concerns 86 insurance policies in which Thrifty financed premiums paid by insurance applicants to Peoples.5 Peoples provides applicants, who would otherwise be unable to obtain insurance, motor vehicle liability insurance in accordance with Massachusetts General Laws. For a variety of reasons set forth later in this decision, Peoples determined that the insureds in question required prepayment of the full premium prior to issuing insurance. In the event that a policy was cancelled, prior to the end of the year, however, the right to the balance of the insured’s pre-paid premium (the “return premium”) accrued to the insured or its assignee.

Thrifty loaned the applicants the full insurance premium amount, and under its note with the insured, it was entitled to a yearly interest rate, a finance charge, several additional fees, and the assignment of the insured’s right to any return premiums.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.