Massachusetts Superior Court November 1, 2005, No. 20021507 (TLP Leasing Programs, Inc. v. Northern Light Technology, LLC)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-11-2005

Haggerty, S. Jane, J.

BACKGROUND

Pursuant to Mass.R.Civ.P. 56, the defendants, Gregory F. Whitten and Ruth Ann Whitten (“the Whit-tens”), DKSW, LLC, David Seuss, and Dean Dussias1 (collectively, “the Defendants”) move for summary judgment in favor of the defendants and against plaintiff TLP Leasing Programs, Inc. (“TLP”), Wellesley Leasing, Inc. (“Wellesley”), Cobblestone Corporation of Northern New England, Inc. (“Cobblestone"), and Heller Financial, Inc. (“Heller”) (collectively the “plaintiffs”), on all claims against them in the First Amended Complaint. Specifically, the counts the plaintiffs have asserted against the defendants are: Counts XIII-XIV (fraudulent transfer, G.L.c. 109A); Counts XV-XVI (civil conspiracy): and Counts XXV-XXVI (G.L.c. 93A, §11).

For the reasons which follow, the defendants’ motion for summary judgment is DENIED.

DISCUSSION

The issue for summary judgment purposes is whether a bridge “loan” from an investor of Northern Light to the company is a capital contribution or a loan. “Whether an advance should be treated as a capital contribution to, rather than creating a debt of, the [company] depends to some extent on the objective intention of the contributor, and in part on whether in particular circumstances, equitable considerations *229require treatment of the advance as a capital contribution.” Yankee Microwave, Inc. v. Petricca Communications Systems, Inc., 53 Mass.App.Ct. 497, 522 (2002), quoting Friedman v. Kurker, 14 Mass.App.Ct. 152, 159-60 (1982).

The circumstances of the bridge “loan” from Northern Light’s shareholder, Gregory and Ruth Whitten raise questions as to their intent at the time the loan was made. When the Whittens made the ten million dollar loan in May of2001, Northern Lights was losing approximately three to four million dollars on a monthly basis. At that time, company officials and shareholders expected to consummate a deal with Lexis-Nexis which would relieve the cash flow problems.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.