Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit August 15, 2005, Docket Nos. 04-3421, 04-3427, 04-3824, 04-3825 (Mirasco, Inc. v. American National Fire Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-08-2005

SUMMARY ORDER

UPON DUE CONSIDERATION, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED that the judgment of the district court be, and it hereby is, VACATED and REMANDED.

This appeal involves an insurance dispute arising out of the importation of frozen beef livers into Egypt. On December 31,1998, the M/V Spero departed Houston, Texas, for Alexandria, Egypt. Miraseo or its customers owned the cargo aboard the M/V Spero, which consisted of 219,072 cartons of frozen beef livers, comprising 132,-535 cartons of Iowa Beef Products (IBP) brand livers, 60,502 cartons of Excel brand livers, and 26,035 cartons of Monfort brand livers. Miraseo had purchased an ocean marine transportation policy issued by defendants American National Fire Insurance Company and Great American Insurance Company (the Insurers) that, inter alia, provided rejection coverage for the cargo.

The M/V Spero arrived in Egypt on January 23, 1999. While the vessel was in transit, Egypt enacted a law, “Decree No. 6,” which banned the importation of IBP products. Egyptian authorities did not allow discharge of the IBP cargo and limited the amount of non-IBP cargo that could be discharged. After various exchanges with the authorities, Miraseo was unable or unwilling to discharge any of the cargo aboard the M/V Spero. The vessel left Alexandria with its cargo still onboard on March 26, 1999. Miraseo made a claim for its losses under the rejection coverage. Litigation ensued. Following a grant of partial summary judgment, the case proceeded to a jury trial that resulted in a judgment in favor of Miraseo.

On appeal, the Insurers assert that the district court erred in ruling on summary judgment that 1) the policy’s rejection clause was not ambiguous; 2) “rejection” meant a refusal to grant entry to goods, and 3) the entire cargo had been rejected. With respect to the Insurers’ first two contentions, we agree with the district court that the term “rejection” was not ambiguous and with its interpretation of that term.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.