Indiana Supreme Court May 3, 2005, 70S01-0409-CR-432 (Ham v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-05-2005

Attorney for Appellant Attorneys for Appellee

Brady J. Lory Steve Carter

Indianapolis, IN Attorney General of Indiana

Richard C. Webster

Matthew D. Fisher

Deputy Attorneys General

Indianapolis, IN

In the

Indiana Supreme Court

_________________________________

No. 70S01-0409-CR-00432

Kimberly S. Ham,

Appellant (Defendant below),

v.

State of Indiana,

Appellee (Plaintiff below).

_________________________________

Appeal from the Rush Superior Court, No. 70D01-0201-CM-019

The Honorable David E. Northam, Judge

_________________________________

On Petition To Transfer from the Indiana Court of Appeals, No. 70A01-0310-

CR-401

_________________________________

May 3, 2005

Shepard, Chief Justice.

There is a division of authority in Indiana concerning whether it is

proper to instruct a jury that it may consider a driver’s refusal to submit

to a chemical test as evidence of intoxication. We hold that lawyers may

argue to jurors that this is so, and jurors may agree or disagree, but that

courts should not so instruct.

Facts and Procedural History

During routine patrol in Rushville on January 18, 2002, Officer Brad

Hatfield spotted Kimberly Ham driving a car left of the centerline. He

followed her, observed her drift left of center three more times, and then

pulled her over. He noticed the smell of alcohol when he arrived at her

vehicle. Ham fumbled through her purse for about forty-four seconds before

producing her driver’s license. Since Hatfield initially requested both

her license and registration, he again asked for her registration, which

she did hand him. She exited the vehicle and stumbled back towards it.

Hatfield asked Ham to step away from the vehicle to separate her from the

alcohol smell, but instead she nodded her head.

Ham failed the horizontal gaze nystagmus test, which tests the

smoothness of the side-to-side movement of a person’s eyes and is seventy-

seven percent accurate. Hatfield noticed her glassy, bloodshot eyes and

her slurred speech.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.