Richmond County Circuit Court April 13, 2005, Case No. LR-2967-1 (Harlow v. Nationwide Insurance)
Also known as
United States · · · 13-04-2005
By Judge Melvin R. Hughes, Jr.
This declaratory judgment proceeding is before the court on cross-motions for summaiy judgment filed by defendant insurance companies. The question presented is whether plaintiff, who has an underlying claim for personal injury damages arising out of an automobile accident, is entitled to underinsured motorist coverage (UIM) from her insurer or from an insurer of the vehicle she was operating at the time of the accident.
The parties agree that the issue arose when plaintiff was test driving an automobile owned by Covey Alexander Motor Sports, a car dealer. Plaintiff claims injury after she was rear ended by defendant Sheri Morris. MetLife provided automobile liability insurance to Morris with coverage limits of $25,000. Plaintiff is insured by defendant Nationwide Insurance Company with UIM coverage of $ 100,000. The vehicle is covered by National Fire & Marine Insurance Company, under a garage keeper’s policy with UIM coverage of $750,000. The question is which of these policies is first in line, the plaintiffs policy or the garage policy.
National argues that, under Ya. Code §§ 38.2-2205 and 38.2-2206, any requirement to furnish its UIM coverage does not apply because its liability coverage does not apply. National says that, even though the garage keeper’s *27exclusion has been held not to apply to UM/UIM coverage, as seen in GEICO v. UUIC, 232 Va. 326 (1986), the case does not control here because the case was decided under a former version of Va. Code § 38.2-2205 and because GEICO held that the exclusion did not apply to UIM/UM coverage on the basis that the statute only referred to liability coverage.
Nationwide argues that plaintiff is an insured under National’s garage policy and that National’s policy has primary UIM coverage. Thus, National should afford its limits of $750,000 to plaintiff.
Plaintiff maintains that she has UIM coverage under Va. Code § 38.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit