Mississippi Supreme Court April 13, 2006, 2004-CA-02352-SCT (Tunica County v. Matthews)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-04-2006

926 So.2d 209 (2006) TUNICA COUNTY, Mississippi, Town of Tunica, Mississippi, and Tunica County Airport Commission v. Ann MATTHEWS, Trustee and John Pritchard, Jr. No. 2004-CA-02352-SCT. Supreme Court of Mississippi. April 13, 2006. *211 W. Whitaker Rayner, Jackson, James E. Woods, Olive Branch, attorneys for appellants. Paul R. Scott, Batesville, attorney for appellees. EN BANC. CARLSON, Justice, for the Court. ¶ 1. This appeal focuses on the issue of the proper methodology for the valuation of land and the determination of the proper amount of just compensation in an eminent domain case. Tunica County brought this action to take certain property from the landowners to use in expanding the existing airport in Tunica County. After a trial, the jury determined the value of the land in question. The only contested issue at trial, and here on appeal, is the value of the land. A hotly contested issue in this case is certain expert testimony concerning the value of the land taken in these eminent domain proceedings. Finding no error, we affirm the final judgment entered by the Tunica County Special Court of Eminent Domain. FACTS AND PROCEEDINGS IN THE TRIAL COURT ¶ 2. Tunica County, the Town of Tunica, and the Tunica County Airport Commission (referred to collectively as Tunica) filed this action in The Special Court of Eminent Domain in Tunica County to condemn certain property being used for agricultural purposes in Tunica County and to acquire the property to use as part of an expansion of the existing airport. That the land was being acquired for public use was not contested. Instead, the only dispute was the amount of money owed to the landowners for the land. The landowners' expert witness, Henry Dunklin, valued the land as having a highest and best use, which is the most feasible use that will produce the greatest profit of commercial or industrial property, and arrived at a price of $4,500 per acre, using comparable sales of commercial or industrial land.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.