Court of Appeals of Maryland August 3, 2006, 128, September Term, 2005 (Smith v. State)
Also known as
United States · · · 03-08-2006
BATTAGLIA, J.
This case presents us with the task of determining whether a witness is deprived of his Sixth Amendment right to effective assistance of counsel when he is held in contempt based, in part, on an unauthorized disclosure of privileged information by his counsel. We hold that the witness in this case,
*190
Jeffrey Smith, received ineffective assistance of counsel when his attorney disclosed the nature of his advice to Smith and his opinion regarding the application of the Fifth Amendment.
Smith also seeks review of the trial judge’s assessment of the merits of his Fifth Amendment claim and the procedures used by the trial judge to impose sanctions for the direct criminal contempt. We conclude that the trial judge committed multiple errors with respect to her determination that Smith did not have a valid basis for asserting his Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination and the procedures that she adhered to when she imposed sanctions for Smith’s contempt.
Background
On November 7, 2003, while the Petitioner, Jeffrey Smith, was serving a sentence for several drug violations, an Assistant State’s Attorney in Baltimore City had Smith brought from prison to court to testify as a prosecution witness in a case in the Circuit Court for Baltimore City,
State v. Morgan, et al.,
case number 102235018-21. When Smith was called to the stand, the following colloquy occurred:
[THE STATE]: Mr. Smith, do you live in Baltimore City?
[SMITH]: Yes.
[THE STA.TE]: How long have you lived in Baltimore City?
[SMITH]: About thirteen, fourteen years.
[THE STATE]: And in what district do you live in?
[SMITH]: Eastern.
[THE STATE]: Eastern District?
[SMITH]: Yes.
[THE STATE]: Which part of the Eastern District?
[SMITH]: East Side.
[THE STATE]: I understand that. Can you tell us the street?
[SMITH]: No, I can’t.
[THE STATE]: Are you refusing to answer?
[SMITH]: Yes.
*191
[THE STATE]: Are you familiar with the 27 hundred block of East Monument Street?
[SMITH]: Yes.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit