Idaho Supreme Court February 22, 2006, 30818 (Hogg v. Wolske)

Also known as

United States · · · 22-02-2006

EISMANN, Justice.

This is an appeal from a judgment quieting title to certain real property, awarding special damages on a claim for slander of title based upon the filing of a void quitclaim deed, and rejecting the defendants’ contention that a deed and contract to reconvey the property executed by their predecessors in interest constituted a mortgage. We affirm the district court and award the respondents attorney fees on appeal.

I. FACTS AND PROCEDURAL HISTORY

The central issue in this case is whether a deed and contract to reeonvey real property constituted a mortgage. Fred and Phyllis Wolske and Vanness and Verda Anderson entered into a written agreement (Agreement) dated March 22, 1975. The Agreement provided that the Wolskes would convey by warranty deed certain real property to the Andersons in exchange for $141,991. It also provided that if the Wolskes paid certain sums, the Andersons would reconvey the property back to them. On March 22, 1975, the Wolskes executed a warranty deed

*552

conveying the real property to the Andersons. The Andersons paid the $141,991 and took possession of the real property.

The documents for the transaction had been prepared by the Wolskes’ attorney, who has retired from practicing law and did not represent the defendants in this case. The Andersons were not represented by counsel at the time. The Wolskes’ attorney recorded the warranty deed conveying the property to the Andersons, but kept the original in his file. He had also prepared a quitclaim deed which the Andersons executed. The Agreement and quitclaim deed were to be placed in escrow at a local bank, but the attorney did not set up the escrow account because the Wolskes did not pay him the fee necessary to do so.

In January 1976, the Wolskes failed to make the first payment of principal due in order to repurchase the property. The Andersons retained counsel, who on May 3, 1976, gave the Wolskes a written sixty-day notice of default as provided in the Agreement.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.