Idaho Supreme Court February 2, 2006, 31804 (Idaho State Bar v. Souza)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-02-2006

BURDICK, Justice.

This is an attorney discipline case. The Idaho State Bar (ISB) filed a formal complaint against John Souza (Souza) charging four counts of misconduct related to his representation of Allen Black (Black). ISB and Souza entered into a stipulation for disciphne and ask that this Court adopt it as the full and final resolution of the formal charges. We decline and impose a different sanction.

I. FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

Black hired Souza to represent him in a personal injury claim relating to injuries he received in a car accident. Black then informed the tortfeasor driver’s insurer, State Farm, that Souza was representing him. State Farm contacted Souza requesting medical bills and reports for Black so that it could conduct an independent medical exam. Souza sent State Farm the medical bills, but despite repeated requests he failed to send medical reports for almost a year. State Farm requested additional medical records and advised Souza that Black’s bills would not be paid until State Farm could evaluate the claim and had a report indicating why the company should pay — an action that could not be completed without the additional medical records.

Nearly two years after Black suffered injuries in the ear accident State Farm was able to conduct an independent medical examination and evaluate the claim. However, Souza did not respond to their settlement attempts. The month prior to the statute of limitations running, State Farm called Souza advising him to file a complaint to preserve the suit. Souza then extended a settlement offer, and State Farm counter-offered the day prior to the statute running. State Farm mailed Souza a letter confirming the counter-offer the day after the statute ran, but Souza failed to respond and the counter offer was subsequently withdrawn. Souza then filed a complaint three days after the statute of hmitations expired.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.