Colorado Court of Appeals February 23, 2006, 03CA0750 (Tatum v. Basin Resources, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-02-2006

KIRSHBAUM

*

, Justice.

Defendant, Basin Resources, Inc., appeals the trial court’s judgment awarding plaintiffs, Jim and Ann Tatum (homeowners), $622,000 in damages plus costs and attorney fees. Homeowners request an award of reasonable attorney fees for this appeal. We affirm and remand with directions.

In 1986 homeowners purchased approximately 153 acres of real property in Las Animas County, Colorado, known as “Solitar-io Ranch.” The property includes a two-story residence in which homeowners live; a bunkhouse; and various barns, corrals, and fences.

In May 1988 Basin’s predecessor, Wyoming Fuel Company, began extracting coal from the Golden Eagle Mine, which is located near homeowners’ property and extends beneath portions of Solitario Ranch. One of the working areas, First North, extended to within 300 feet southwest of homeowners’ residence. Another working area was located approximately 1600 to 1700 feet northeast of the residence. Because of poor conditions in the mine, including a soft mine floor and large amounts of water entering the mine, in mid-1988 Wyoming Fuel Company ceased mining operations and allowed the mine to be flooded.

In 1991 Wyoming Fuel Company was renamed Basin Resources, Inc.

After the mine closed homeowners noticed damage to their residence. Subsequent investigations indicated the damages were attributable to subsidence in the Golden Eagle Mine’s workings, and, in 1992, homeowners filed suit against Basin. They alleged various claims, including breach of contract, subsidence damage to .their property, and damage caused by the construction of a ventilation shaft. Homeowners did not allege any future damages and did not request compensation for any possible prospective injury. Homeowners made certain repairs to their residence while the civil action was pending.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.