Court of Civil Appeals of Oklahoma September 12, 2006, 101,832 (CIMMARRON TRANSP., LLC v. Butler)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-09-2006

151 P.3d 920 (2006) 2007 OK CIV APP 1 CIMMARRON TRANSPORTATION, L.L.C., Plaintiff/Appellant, v. Sharon BUTLER, County Assessor of Seminole County, State of Oklahoma, Jim Hardin, County Treasurer of Seminole County, State of Oklahoma, and the Seminole County Board of Equalization, Defendants/Appellees. No. 101,832. Court of Civil Appeals of Oklahoma, Division No. 4. September 12, 2006. Rehearing Denied December 5, 2006. Mike Mordy, Mordy & Mordy, P.C., Ardmore, OK, for Appellant. Timothy L. Olsen, Assistant District Attorney, Wewoka, OK, for Appellees. Released for Publication by Order of the Court of Civil Appeals of Oklahoma, Division No. 4. JOHN F. REIF, Judge. ¶ 1 This case concerns the valuation of 45.5 miles of pipeline in Seminole County for ad valorem taxation in 2003. There is no dispute the pipeline is subject to ad valorem taxation in 2003 on the basis of its fair cash value as of January 1, 2003. The controversy between the owner of the pipeline, Cimmarron Transportation, L.L.C., and the Seminole County Assessor is how the fair cash value of this pipeline should be determined. ¶ 2 Cimmarron has contended that the fair cash value should be based on the price Cimmarron paid January 1, 2002, to acquire a package of 1,835.96 miles of pipeline that included the 45.5 miles at issue. The permile unit price for just the pipe was $70 per mile, or $3,255 for the 45.5 miles of pipe in Seminole County. The County Assessor disagreed and has contended that the fair cash *921 value should be based on the replacement cost less depreciation. The County Assessor determined the replacement cost was $528,181.56. ¶ 3 Cimmarron appealed the County Assessor's valuation to the Seminole County Board of Equalization. The Board of Equalization also used replacement cost to determine the pipeline's fair cash value. However, the Board fixed the fair cash value of the pipeline at $438,204.62.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.