Bankruptcy Appellate Panel of the Sixth Circuit October 13, 2006, 05-8075 (In re: Ronald Perron v.)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-10-2006

By order of the Bankruptcy Appellate Panel, the precedential effect

of this decision is limited to the case and parties pursuant to

6th Cir. BAP LBR 8013-1(b). See also 6th Cir. BAP LBR 8010-1(c).

File Name: 06b0017n.06

BANKRUPTCY APPELLATE PANEL OF THE SIXTH CIRCUIT

In re: RONALD JOSEPH PERRON and )

MARY ANN PERRON, )

)

Debtors. )

_______________________________________ )

)

RONALD JOSEPH PERRON and )

MARY ANN PERRON, ) No. 05-8075

)

Appellants, )

)

v. )

)

eCAST SETTLEMENT CORP., )

)

Appellee. )

_______________________________________ )

Appeal from the United States Bankruptcy Court

for the Western District of Michigan, at Marquette.

No. 03-90592.

Argued: August 23, 2006

Decided and Filed: October 13, 2006

Before: AUG, SCOTT, and WHIPPLE, Bankruptcy Appellate Panel Judges.

____________________

COUNSEL

ARGUED: Allan J. Rittenhouse, Iron Mountain, Michigan, for Appellants. Alane A. Becket,

BECKET & LEE, Malvern, Pennsylvania, for Appellee. ON BRIEF: Allan J. Rittenhouse, Iron

Mountain, Michigan, for Appellants. James W. Batchelor, TROTT & TROTT, Grand Rapids,

Michigan, for Appellee.

____________________

OPINION

____________________

J. VINCENT AUG, JR., Chief Bankruptcy Appellate Panel Judge. The chapter 7 debtors,

Ronald Joseph and Mary Ann Perron (the “Debtors”), appeal the order of the bankruptcy court that

overruled their objections to the amended proofs of claims filed by eCAST Settlement Corporation

(“eCAST”), as assignee of two credit card creditors. For the reasons that follow, the order of the

bankruptcy court is AFFIRMED.

I. ISSUE ON APPEAL

Whether a debtor’s claim objection is sufficient to disallow a proof of claim where the

objection (i) does not actually contest the debtor’s liability or the amount of the debt and (ii) is based

solely on the argument that the proof of claim is technically insufficient because the creditor attached

only a summary of the basis for the claim and failed to attach supporting documentation.

II.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.