Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit October 16, 2006, 04-1495 (Kircher, Carl v. Putnam Funds Trust)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-10-2006

In the

United States Court of Appeals

For the Seventh Circuit

____________

Nos. 04-1495, 04-1496, 04-1608, 04-1628, 04-1650, 04-1651,

04-1660, 04-1661, 04-2162, 04-2687, 05-2895, 05-2896,

05-2911, 05-2912, 05-2981, 05-3011, 05-3389, 05-3390,

05-3548, 05-3558, 05-3559, 05-3585 & 05-3586

IN THE MATTER OF:

MUTUAL FUND MARKET-TIMING LITIGATION

____________

Appeals from the United States District Court

for the Southern District of Illinois.

____________

SUBMITTED JULY 25, 2006—DECIDED OCTOBER 16, 2006

____________

Before EASTERBROOK, RIPPLE, and WOOD, Circuit Judges.

EASTERBROOK, Circuit Judge. Our opinion in Kircher

v. Putnam Funds Trust, 403 F.3d 478 (7th Cir. 2005)

(Kircher II), explains the nature of these suits against

mutual funds. Plaintiffs maintain that the funds are liable

because they were vulnerable to arbitrageurs who exploited

the fact that, when the mutual funds’ shares were priced (at

4 P.M. New York time every business day), the funds valued

securities of foreign issuers at their closing prices in the

issuers’ home markets rather than the latest trading price

in any liquid market. If prices move after the issuers’ home-

market close, but before 4 P.M. in New York, the difference

creates arbitrage opportunities at the expense of investors

who follow a buy-and-hold strategy. Plaintiffs contend that

2 Nos. 04-1495 et al.

the funds should have made arbitrage unprofitable by

changing the rules for valuing the securities in the funds’

portfolios or imposing fees on short-swing trades.

Kircher II held that claims of this kind arise under federal

securities law because disclosure of the funds’ practices and

vulnerabilities would preclude recovery, and that, because

plaintiffs have not taken advantage of the exception for

derivative litigation, the state-law claims are preempted by

the Securities Litigation Uniform Standards Act of 1998

(SLUSA) even though at least some of the investors held

their shares throughout the class periods.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.