North Carolina Industrial Commission February 10, 2006, I.C. NO. 019947. (Smythe v. Waffle House)
Also known as
United States · · · 10-02-2006
*********** The Full Commission entered its Opinion and Award in this matter on May 15, 2003, in which the Commission found there to be no good grounds upon which to set aside a Compromise Settlement Agreement (CSA) approved by the Commission by former Deputy Commissioner Richard Ford on May 31, 2001, and amended by Order of Deputy Commissioner Bradley Houser on October 17, 2001. The Court of Appeals, upon review of the plaintiff's appeal from the Full Commission, held that the settlement agreement failed to meet the requirements of Industrial Commission Rule 502 (2)(h), and found: Here, the face of the compromise settlement agreement indicates that plaintiff had not returned to work for the same or greater wages and it is undisputed that plaintiff was unrepresented when she entered the agreement in May 2001. Thus, [the] more specific requirements of [Industrial Commission] Rule 502(2)(h) apply to the agreement here. However, the settlement agreement here does not contain any of the information required under Rule 502(2)(h). It contains no mention of plaintiff's age, educational level, past vocational training, or past work experience . . . [T]his Court held in Atkins that it is impermissible for the Commission to determine that a settlement agreement was `fair and just' without medical *Page 2 records required by Rule 503. 154 N.C. App. At 514, 571 S.E.2d at 867. Likewise, we conclude that [it] is impermissible for the Commission to make a determination regarding the fairness of a settlement agreement without the information required by 502(2)(h). Based upon the Opinion of the Court of Appeals, the defendant contends that the parties can comply with Rule 502(2)(h) by submitting to the Commission the medical records of the plaintiff as well as information regarding the plaintiff's vocational and educational history and, upon receipt of such documents, the Commission can then review the settlement agreement reached by the parties.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit