District Court of Appeal of Florida March 24, 2006, No. 2D05-2629 (J.A.R. v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-03-2006

CANADY, Judge.

J.A.R. appeals his juvenile adjudication for battery and obstructing an officer without violence and the disposition order committing him to a moderate-risk residential placement. Because the trial court’s disposition is not supported by competent, substantial evidence, we reverse the disposition order and remand for a new disposition hearing.

Background

The trial court held an adjudicatory hearing and found J.A.R. guilty of battery against his girlfriend and obstructing an officer without violence during the officer’s attempt to arrest him for the battery. Prior to sentencing, the Department of Juvenile Justice filed a predisposition report, recommending that J.A.R. be placed in a low-risk residential program. The predisposition report referenced a psychological evaluation report prepared by Eric L. Rosen, Ph.D., a licensed psychologist, which was submitted to the trial court along with the predisposition report. At the disposition hearing, defense counsel requested probation in lieu of a residential program. Defense counsel argued that J.A.R. could receive anger management and other treatment at home. The State responded that J.A.R. had been unsuccessful with probation in the past. The State *605recognized the recommendation of the Department but stated that “low-risk residential may not be appropriate.” The State suggested that “a moderate-risk residential may be more appropriate” based on a “myriad of programs ... available in a moderate-risk residential placement that would not be available to him in a low-risk residential placement.” Defense counsel replied that the “Department,... had the benefit of a staffing” and urged the trial court to follow the Department’s recommendation if the trial court was not inclined to give him probation. The trial court placed J.A.R.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.