District Court of Appeal of Florida March 29, 2006, No. 2D04-2838 (McMonigle v. McMonigle)
Also known as
United States · · · 29-03-2006
DAVIS, Judge.
Robert A. McMonigle challenges the trial court’s final judgment granting attorney’s fees to Ronald J. McMonigle, as Personal Representative of the Estate of John E. McMonigle, Sr. (“the Estate”), pursuant to section 57.105, Florida Statutes (1997).1 We reverse.
Robert A. McMonigle and Ronald J. McMonigle are two of the four children of John E. McMonigle, Sr. (“the Decedent”). By the terms of his will, the Decedent devised his estate to his four children in equal shares and named Ronald as Personal Representative.
Prior to his death, the Decedent had certain physical limitations that required him to have assistance in performing even routine activities. For nearly three years prior to the Decedent’s death in 1999, Ronald assisted him with his banking and business affairs. During that time, Ronald stopped working and asked the Decedent for financial assistance. From 1996 to 1999, Ronald received checks worth approximately $84,000 from the Decedent. Ronald admitted that he did not repay these funds.
After the Decedent’s will was admitted to probate, Robert concluded that the money given to Ronald prior to their father’s death was in the nature of a loan rather than a gift. Accordingly, Robert took the position that Ronald should repay the money to the Estate. To secure this repayment, Robert filed a statement of claim in the Estate for $80,000.2 Ronald, as Personal Representative, filed an objection to the claim.
Believing that probate law required the filing of a civil action within thirty days of the filing of the objection,3 Robert then filed a separate cause of action in which he asked for declaratory relief in the form of a determination of what interest the Estate had in the $80,000 received by Ronald prior to the Decedent’s death. Robert also asked that a constructive trust be ordered to protect the $80,000 for the benefit of the Estate.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit