Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit January 19, 2006, 05-1242 (Jacksonville Airport, Incorporated v. Michkeldel, Incorporated)

Also known as

United States · · · 19-01-2006

LUTTIG, Circuit Judge.

Appellant, Jacksonville Airport, Inc. (JAI), voted to reject the Chapter 11 plan of reorganization for appellee, Michkeldel, Inc. Michkeldel refused to count JAI’s vote, maintaining that JAI was not entitled to vote since its claim was not “allowed” under the Bankruptcy Code. The bankruptcy court held that Michkeldel did not have to count JAI’s vote, and the district court affirmed. JAI appealed. We affirm.

I.

Michkeldel filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy in December 2002. J.A. 22, 29. At the time of Michkeldel’s bankruptcy filing, a suit in which Michkeldel and JAI were adverse was pending in Florida state court. The bankruptcy court granted relief from the automatic stay to allow the Florida court to enter a final judgment and to permit the parties to appeal that judgment.

Id.

at 58-59. JAI was successful in the Florida trial court and filed an unsecured claim for the state court judgment in Michkeldel’s bankruptcy proceeding.

Id.

at 99-100. Michkeldel objected to JAI’s claim, arguing that the claim should not be allowed becausé Michkeldel intended to appeal the state court judgment.

Id.

at 100. JAI took no immediate action to oppose Michkeldel’s objection.

In tallying the votes for acceptance or rejection of its plan of reorganization,

*731

Miehkeldel refused to count JAI’s vote to reject the plan.

See id.

at 138. Michkel-del justified its failure to count JAI’s vote on the rationale that Michkeldel’s uncontested objection to JAI’s claim prevented JAI from being entitled to vote on the plan. JAI learned that its vote had not been counted at the bankruptcy court’s confirmation hearing, which occurred two days after the deadline for voting on the plan. At the confirmation hearing, JAI orally petitioned the bankruptcy court to recognize its vote against the plan, but the court deemed this petition untimely because the deadline for voting on the plan had passed.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.