Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit March 9, 2006, 05-3512 (Xue Y. Ren v. Alberto R. Gonzales)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-03-2006

POSNER, Circuit Judge.

Xue Ren was ordered removed from the United States by an immigration judge after the judge denied her request for asylum and other relief. The Board of Immigration Appeals affirmed, and later denied her motion to reopen the proceeding. After she filed a petition in this court for review of the denial of the motion to reopen, the Justice Department moved us to remand the case to the Board “for further consideration of Petitioner’s requests for asylum, withholding of deportation and Convention Against Torture protection in light of current country conditions in the People’s Republic of China.” There was no further elaboration. The petitioner indicated her agreement with the motion.

The Department’s motion, in part because of its extreme brevity, raised questions in our mind. It was not a formal confession of error; nor did it seem to be a motion to remand for the limited purpose of considering the possible bearing of newly discovered evidence, because the motion stated that, “if granted, [the motion] brings the present matter on review to conclusion.” We were concerned that if the Department was attempting to confess error, its attempt was defective because its failure to give reasons prevented us from evaluating the merits of the confession. When the Department confesses error on a federal district court, “our judicial obligations compel us to examine independently the errors confessed.”

Young v. United States,

315 U.S. 257, 258-59, 62 S.Ct. 510, 86 L.Ed. 832 (1942). See also, e.g.,

Sibron v. New York,

392 U.S. 40, 58, 88 S.Ct. 1889, 20 L.Ed.2d 917 (1968).

To allay our concerns, we invited the parties to file supplemental memoranda addressing the following questions:

1. Whether the Board of Immigration Appeals has any policy-making function under current law, or is instead an adjudicatory body only.

2.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.