Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit March 23, 2006, 05-1480 (Stolt-Nielsen, S.A. Stolt-Nielsen Transportation Group Ltd. Richard B. Wingfield v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 23-03-2006

AMBRO, Circuit Judge.

This case raises a significant constitutional question of first impression in this Circuit: whether federal courts have authority, consistent with the separation of powers, to enjoin the executive branch from filing an indictment. Although federal courts have this authority in narrow circumstances, we conclude that this is not

*179

such a case and therefore reverse the District Court’s judgment to the contrary.

I.

A. Background

Appellee Stolt-Nielsen, S.A., through its subsidiary StolWNielsen Transportation Group Ltd. (collectively “Stolt-Nielsen” or the “Company”), is a leading supplier of parcel tanker shipping services. In March 2002, StolWNielsen’s general counsel, Paul O’Brien, resigned. According to a complaint O’Brien filed against Stolt-Nielsen in Connecticut Superior Court in November 2002, and a subsequent article in

The Wall Street Journal,

O’Brien advised his superiors of illegal collusive trading practices between Stolt-Nielsen and two of its competitors, and resigned after the Company failed to take action to resolve the problem. On receiving O’Brien’s November 2002 complaint, StolWNielsen hired John Nannes, a former Deputy Assistant Attorney General in the Antitrust Division at the U.S. Department of Justice, to conduct an internal investigation of possible antitrust violations by the Company and advise it regarding any criminal liability.

On November 22, 2002, Nannes met with the chairman of Stolb-Nielsen’s tanker division, Samuel Cooperman. Cooper-man informed Nannes that O’Brien “rais[ed] some antitrust concerns” in early 2002, and that in response Stolt-Nielsen revised its antitrust compliance policy and disseminated it to its employees and competitors. Cooperman also told Nannes that he believed an internal investigation would demonstrate that the Company was in violation of federal antitrust laws and asked Nannes about the possibility of leniency from the Department of Justice.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.