Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit July 25, 2006, 05-1930 (Williams v. Bitner)

Also known as

United States · · · 25-07-2006

455 F.3d 186 Henry WILLIAMS, Appellee, v. Robert S. BITNER; Jay Stidd; Robert W. Meyers; Terry L. Whitman; Robin L. Kerstetter; Gregory P. Gaertner; Franklin J. Tennis; George Snedeker; Gary Emel; Scott Wyland, United States of America (Intervernor in District Court) Robert S. Bitner; Jay Stidd; Robert W. Meyers; Terry L. Whitman; Robin L. Kerstetter; G.P. Gaertner; F.J. Tennis; George Snedeker; Gary Emel; Scott Wayland, Appellants. No. 05-1930. United States Court of Appeals, Third Circuit. Argued February 28, 2006. Filed July 25, 2006. Barbara Adams, General Counsel, Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, Michael A. Farnan, Chief Counsel, Raymond W. Dorian, Assistant Counsel (Argued), Pennsylvania Department of Corrections, Camp Hill, PA, for Appellants. Michael Cooke (Argued), Pennsylvania Institutional Law Project, Philadelphia, PA, for Appellee. Before SLOVITER and FUENTES, Circuit Judges, and BRODY,* District Judge. FUENTES, Circuit Judge. 1 Henry Williams, a Muslim inmate assigned to work as a cook in his prison's kitchen, was ordered to help prepare a meal that included pork. Williams refused, explaining that his religious beliefs prohibited him from handling pork. As a result, Williams was fired from his kitchen job, cited for misconduct, and punished accordingly. Williams brought this action against numerous prison officials, alleging violations of his rights under the First and Fourteenth Amendments and the Religious Land Use and Institutionalized Persons Act. The District Court dismissed Williams's Fourteenth Amendment claim but refused to grant qualified immunity to the prison officials with respect to the remaining claims. We are asked to determine whether, for the purposes of qualified immunity, the conduct alleged by Williams constituted a violation of his "clearly established" rights. For the reasons that follow, we will affirm the District Court's denial of qualified immunity with respect to Williams's First Amendment claim. I.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.