Nevada Supreme Court July 13, 2006, No. 43194 (Bongiovi v. Sullivan)
Also known as
United States · · · 13-07-2006
OPINION
By the Court,
Rose, C. J.:
Julie Jones sought cosmetic surgery and consulted with various plastic surgeons, including appellant Joseph Bongiovi, Jr., M.D., and respondent Walter Sullivan, M.D. On two separate occasions, while Jones was consulting with Bongiovi, Bongiovi told Jones that Sullivan had recently killed a woman while performing the same surgery Jones was scheduled for. Jones canceled her surgery with Sullivan and, sometime later, told Sullivan what Bongiovi had said.
Sullivan sued Bongiovi for defamation, arguing that Bongiovi’s statements were slanderous per se. Following a trial, the jury found in favor of Sullivan and awarded him $250,000 in compensatory damages and $250,000 in punitive damages. Bongiovi appeals, arguing that a new trial is warranted because the district court (1) abused its discretion by refusing to continue the trial to accommodate Bongiovi’s counsel’s medical condition, (2) erred by concluding that Sullivan was not a limited-purpose public figure, and (3) improperly allowed inflammatory hearsay testimony. Bon-giovi also argues, among other things, that the damages awards must be set aside because (1) the compensatory damages award was excessive, and the district court erroneously awarded prejudgment interest on future damages; and (2) the punitive damages award was improper because Sullivan failed to prove that Bon-giovi’s statements were made with the requisite malice, fraud, or oppression to support punitive damages, and the award was excessive and improperly based on attorney fees.
We conclude that a new trial is unwarranted and the compensatory and punitive damages awards were proper. Regarding the denial of the request for a trial continuance, Bongiovi was adequately represented by other counsel, the district court delayed the start of trial by one week to allow Bongiovi’s substitute counsel to familiarize himself with the case, and Bongiovi has not demonstrated that he was prejudiced by the denial.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit