Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit January 24, 2006, No. 04-3000-CV (Alliance for Environmental Renewal, Inc. v. Pyramid Crossgates Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-01-2006
JON O. NEWMAN, Circuit Judge.
This appeal of a dismissal of claims under the Clean Water Act, 33 U.S.C. § 1251 et seq. (“CWA”), concerns the proper course for a district court when confronted with a motion to dismiss both on the merits and for lack of subject matter jurisdiction in circumstances where subject matter jurisdiction is adequately pleaded but the underlying jurisdictional facts are in question. Plaintiffs-Appellants Alliance for Environmental Renewal, Inc., and Save the Pine Bush, Inc., appeal from the May 20, 2004, judgment of the District Court for the Northern District of New York (Gary L. Sharpe, District Judge) dismissing their CWA claims against Defendants-Appellees Pyramid Crossgates Company and several affiliated entities (collectively “Crossgates”). The District Court dismissed for lack of statutory standing, a ruling premised on the Court’s view that salt is not a pollutant under the CWA. We hold that the District Court must first resolve the subject matter jurisdictional issue on which the Plaintiffs’ Article III standing depends before awarding either side a judgment that is, in essence, a judgment on the merits. The Court may resolve the factual issues concerning *84jurisdiction either on a summary judgment motion, if appropriate, or, if not, after an evidentiary hearing. Because the Article III jurisdictional facts have not yet been determined, we vacate and remand.
Background
The Plaintiffs-Appellants are non-profit organizations dedicated to preserving the environment. Crossgates operates a shopping mall in Guilderland, New York. The complaint alleges that Crossgates discharges waste-water into the Krum Kill Creek pursuant to a permit issued by the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (“NYSDEC”). Among other things, this permit limits the concentration of sodium chloride — salt—in Crossgates’ waste-water discharges.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit