Michigan Supreme Court July 7, 2006, 127212 (COMBEN v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 07-07-2006

Order Michigan Supreme Court

Lansing, Michigan

July 7, 2006 Clifford W. Taylor,

Chief Justice

127212 Michael F. Cavanagh

Elizabeth A. Weaver

Marilyn Kelly

Maura D. Corrigan

SHERRY COMBEN, ANTRIM COUNTY Robert P. Young, Jr.

TREASURER, Stephen J. Markman,

Plaintiff-Appellee, Justices

v SC: 127212

COA: 248963

Antrim CC: 02-007860-PS

STATE OF MICHIGAN, and

DEPARTMENT OF TREASURY,

Defendants-Appellants,

and

BLACK STONE MINERALS CO., L.P.,

DOMINION RESERVES, INC., WOLVERINE

GAS AND OIL COMPANY, INC., EUGENIE R.

ANDERSON, STEPHEN WARD DEVINE,

ELIZABETH PALMER DEVINE,

MICHAEL EDMUND DEVINE, SUZANNE

LEE DEVINE, WILLIAM W. DUNN,

DAVID W. FAY, EDWIN R. FAY,

PETER W. FAY, ROBERT A. FAY,

ROSAMOND S. FISHER, FREDERICK T.

GOLDING, NANCY HAMILTON, LISA

MARRIOTT JONES, DAPHNE FAY

LANDRY, GEORGE S. LEISURE, JR.,

PETER R. LEISURE, FLORA NINELLES,

MARJORIE S. RICHARDSON, JAMES W.

RILEY, JR., WILLIAM A. RILEY,

BARBARA F. ROSENBERG, ELIZABETH

R. P. SHAW, ANN WARD SPAETH,

FREDERICK S. STRONG, III, A. W.

ROBERT, STRONG REVOCABLE TRUST,

and EUGENIE S. KAUFFMAN,

Defendants-Appellees.

_______________________________________/

2

On order of the Court, leave to appeal having been granted, 474 Mich 893 (2005),

and the briefs and oral argument of the parties having been considered by the Court, we

hereby VACATE the August 31, 2004 judgment of the Court of Appeals. MCR

7.302(G)(1). The court lacked jurisdiction where the appellants were not aggrieved by

the trial court's decision, which fully protected appellants' ownership interests in the

subject properties at issue. MCR 7.203(A).

TAYLOR, C.J., concurs and states as follows:

I concur in the majority order but write separately to emphasize that it is in accord

with the majority opinion in Federated Ins Co v Oakland Co Rd Comm (Docket

No. 126886), ___ Mich ___ (2006). Justice Weaver’s dissent is premised on her

disagreement with Federated. Her view, however, is not controlling. Rather, the

majority’s opinion in Federated speaks for itself.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.