North Dakota Supreme Court August 24, 2006, 20050444 (Peoples State Bank of Truman, Inc. v. Molstad Excavating, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-08-2006

combined-opinion

VANDE WALLE, Chief Justice.

[¶ 1] Peoples State Bank of Truman (“Bank”), now known as Profinium Financial, brought a summary judgment motion against Molstad Excavating (“Molstad”) claiming the Bank is entitled to $20,000 being held by Molstad. FGOH20 (“Fargo Water”) also brought a summary judgment motion claiming it was entitled to the $20,000 held by Molstad. Judgment was entered in favor of Fargo Water and the Bank appealed. We affirm.

I

[¶ 2] Haycraft Construction, Inc. (“Haycraft”) borrowed money from the Bank. To secure repayment of this debt, Haycraft executed a security agreement pledging as collateral its present and future inventory, present and future accounts, present and future contract rights, and all machinery, equipment, vehicles, furniture, and fixtures then known or thereafter acquired. The Bank filed the security agreement with the Minnesota Secretary of State. This assignment allowed the Bank to collect money owed to Haycraft by other parties if Haycraft failed to pay back the money it borrowed from the Bank.

[¶ 3] The City of Grand Forks awarded Molstad, as the general contractor, a contract to perform work for the City. In February 2002, Molstad entered into a subcontract with Haycraft (“Molstad/Hay-craft agreement”) under which Haycraft would perform some of the work necessary to complete the project for Grand Forks and Molstad would pay Haycraft for its work.

[¶ 4] Paragraph 2 of the Molstad/Hay-craft agreement allowed Molstad to withhold any money it owed to Haycraft if Molstad received notice of any claim arising out of the labor or materials that were furnished for the project. Molstad could also withhold any amount due to Haycraft on account of any actions or failures to act by Haycraft in the performance of the subcontract. Under the Molstad/Haycraft agreement, Haycraft explicitly agreed to pay all costs in connection with completing the project and also agreed to pay the bills as they became due.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.