Louisiana Court of Appeal December 28, 2007, CA-0007-0790 (Nicole and Matthew Young v. C. Benny Thibodeaux, O.D.)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-12-2007

NOT FOR PUBLICATION

STATE OF LOUISIANA

COURT OF APPEAL, THIRD CIRCUIT

07-790

NICOLE AND MATTHEW YOUNG

VERSUS

C. BENNY THIBODEAUX, O.D., EYEMASTERS, INC.,

AND ABC INSURANCE COMPANY

**********

APPEAL FROM THE

FIFTEENTH JUDICIAL DISTRICT COURT

PARISH OF LAFAYETTE, NO. 2004-2915-L

HONORABLE MARILYN C. CASTLE, PRESIDING

**********

SYLVIA R. COOKS

JUDGE

**********

Court composed of Sylvia R. Cooks, Marc T. Amy and Elizabeth A. Pickett,

Judges.

AFFIRMED.

H. Alston Johnson, III

F. Scott Kaiser

Erin Wilder-Doomes

Suite 701, City Plaza

445 North Boulevard

Baton Rouge, LA 70802

(225) 346-0285

COUNSEL FOR APPELLEES:

Brown & Brown, Inc., Optometric Protector Plan

and Optical Services Protector Plan.

Michael W. Adley

Judice & Adley, APLC

P.O. Drawer 51769

Lafayette, LA 70505-1769

(337) 235-2405

COUNSEL FOR APPELLANT:

C. Benny Thibodeaux, O.D.

COOKS, Judge.

Plaintiffs, Nicole and Matthew Young, filed suit against Dr. C. Benny

Thibodeaux and others seeking damages for alleged malpractice. The Youngs

claimed on February 23, 2002, Dr. Thibodeaux failed to diagnose a melanoma of

Nicole’s left eye, allegedly resulting in loss of the eye.

Upon receipt of the petition, Dr. Thibodeaux forwarded the suit to his insurer,

NCMIC Insurance Company. The policy with NCMIC was an occurrence policy.

NCMIC advised Dr. Thibodeaux that its policy did not provide coverage for the claim

asserted because the inception date of the policy was May 5, 2003, which was after

the treatment at issue. Dr. Thibodeaux also provided the petition for damages to his

prior insurer, Certain Underwriters at Lloyds. Dr. Thibodeaux was informed that no

coverage was provided by the Lloyds policy because the claim was not made during

the life of that policy. The Lloyds policy was a claims made policy.

In effect, Dr. Thibodeaux became aware he had a gap in his insurance

coverage. Dr.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.