Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit August 29, 2007, 05-16915 (Navarette v. United States)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-08-2007

combined-opinion

500 F.3d 914 (2007) Ricardo Angel NAVARETTE, Plaintiff-Appellant, and Kelly Kaslar, Plaintiff, v. UNITED STATES of America, Defendant-Appellee. No. 05-16915. United States Court of Appeals, Ninth Circuit. Argued and Submitted July 13, 2007. Filed August 29, 2007. *915 Amitai Schwartz (argued), Lisa M. Sitkin, Law Offices of Amitai Schwartz, Emeryville, CA, for the plaintiff-appellant. Kevin V. Ryan, United States Attorney, Joann M. Swanson, Chief, Civil Division, Owen P. Martikan (argued), Assistant United States Attorney, San Francisco, CA, for the defendant-appellee. Before: PROCTER HUG, JR., PAMELA ANN RYMER and RAYMOND C. FISHER, Circuit Judges. Opinion by Judge FISHER; Dissent by Judge RYMER. FISHER, Circuit Judge: Ricardo Navarette was severely injured when he fell off a cliff at a campground operated by the Army Corps of Engineers (Army Corps) near Lake Sonoma in northern California. Alleging that the campground staff had been negligent in failing to undertake safety precautions after a "use path" had developed that led directly from his campsite to the cliff's edge, Navarette sued the government for damages under the Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA). The district court granted summary judgment for the government, finding that the discretionary function exception barred jurisdiction under the FTCA. We hold that the discretionary function exception does not apply and reverse. I. Background Navarette was injured in April 1997 at the Liberty Glen Campground, which the Army Corps owns and operates. On the night of his accident, Navarette was camping with his brother and a group of friends at a site numbered "C-88." Navarette and a friend, Kelly Kaslar, walked down an unmarked path from site C-88 in the direction of flashlights visible at another campsite. The path led directly to the edge of a cliff. Navarette and Kaslar fell off the cliff and fell approximately 30 feet to the rocks below.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.