Court of Appeals for the First Circuit August 6, 2007, 05-2293, 05-2293 (Hatfield-Bermudez v. Aldanondo-Rivera)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-08-2007

LYNCH, Circuit Judge.

A jury awarded Ruth Hatfield-Bermu-dez compensatory and punitive damages after defendants José Aldanondo-Rivera and Aida L. Berrios-Gomez failed to renew Hatfield’s position as head of an adult education night school. The jury concluded that this non-renewal violated Hatfield’s First Amendment political affiliation rights, as well as her rights under Article 1802 of the Puerto Rico Civil Code.

See

P.R. Laws Ann. tit. 31, § 5141. The magistrate judge, presiding with the consent of the parties, vacated the political discrimination verdict for lack of key evidence. The judge also, acting well within his powers, granted a mistrial on the Article 1802 verdict based on improper comments by plaintiffs counsel. On reconsideration, the magistrate judge reversed the grant of the mistrial after deciding that his curative instructions had been sufficient.

Hatfield appeals the grant of the Rule 50(b) motion on her political discrimination claim, as well as the earlier dismissal of a due process claim that she had also brought. Aldanondo and Berrios appeal the judgment against them on the Article 1802 claim. We affirm.

I. BACKGROUND & PROCEDURAL HISTORY

A.

Dismissal of the Due Process Claim

Hatfield’s complaint alleged that she had been working in her position for eight years under successive one-year contracts. Hatfield alleged that when her contract was not renewed for the 2001-2002 school year, the defendants deprived her of a property right without due process of law.

The defendants moved to dismiss the due process claim on the basis that Hatfield’s own pleadings demonstrated that she had no property right in her continued employment. In an opinion dated February 11, 2003, the district court agreed and dismissed the due process claim.

For reasons unknown, defense counsel apparently believed the claim was still in the case by the time of trial, and he moved to dismiss this claim pursuant to Rule 50(a) after the close of the evidence.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.