Superior Court of Pennsylvania June 12, 2007 (Susquehanna Patriot Commercial Leasing Co. v. Holper Industries, Inc.)

Also known as

United States · · · 12-06-2007

OPINION BY

BOWES, J.:

¶ 1 At issue in this case is the enforceability of a “floating” forum selection clause in equipment leases. We conclude that the clause is enforceable under Pennsylvania law and therefore reverse and remand.

¶ 2 Appellant, Susquehanna Patriot Commercial Leasing Company, Inc., was assigned various leases for telecommunications equipment by NorVergenee, Inc. The background of the leases in question bears repeating since there has been nationwide litigation, including litigation by various states’ attorneys general and the Federal Trade Commission, over leases negotiated by NorVergenee.

See http://www.ftc.gov. opa/2005/07/norvergence. htm; http://www.

attomeygeneral.gov/consumers.

1

N orVer-gence approached small businesses and consumers and represented that they could obtain a thirty-to-sixty percent savings on telephone, cellular, and internet bills by leasing a piece of equipment identified as a Matrix. NorVergenee marketed its services as integrated, long-term packages that included provision of the telecommunication services, and leases were negotiated based on provision of those services. Meanwhile, the Matrix was a standard router or firewall device that was not capable of providing any reduced savings on the telecommunications services and was worth a fraction of its selling price.

¶ 3 The leases were then immediately assigned by NorVergenee to third-party finance companies, including Appellant herein. NorVergence’s contract with the purchaser stated that the money on the rental agreements for the equipment was owed regardless of whether NorVergenee provided the promised telecommunications services, which, as noted, were integral to the equipment lease. After collecting millions from the equipment lease assignments, NorVergenee declared bankruptcy,

*281

the purchasers of the Matrix stopped receiving telecommunications services, and in turn, they stopped making payments under the leases to the finance companies.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.