Supreme Court of Delaware February 16, 2007, 54, 2007 (In Re the State for a Writ of Mandamus)
Also known as
United States · · · 16-02-2007
HOLLAND, Justice:
This Court has before it a petition that seeks to invoke its original jurisdiction for the purpose of issuing an extraordinary writ. The petition was filed by the State of Delaware and requests that this Court issue a writ of mandamus to Superior Court Judge Jerome 0. Herlihy. The underlying matter that gave rise to the present proceeding is an evidentiary ruling during an ongoing capital murder trial.
James E. Cooke (“Cooke”), who is represented by two attorneys, is charged with First Degree Capital Murder and other serious offenses, and has pleaded not guilty. On the basis of psychiatric examinations and other evidence, Cooke’s counsel intend to contest the State’s proof of guilt, but also plan, concurrently, to present mitigation evidence of Cooke’s mental illness. Several days prior to the beginning of trial, Cooke’s defense counsel advised the trial judge that, based on their conversations with Cooke, he was not in agreement with presenting evidence of mental illness that would support a verdict of guilty but mentally ill (“GBMI”).
The State seeks review of an order issued January 30, 2007, in which the Superior Court denied a motion made by prosecutors to preclude presentation by Cooke’s defense counsel, during the guilt phase of the trial, of any evidence that would sup
*1153
port a GBMI verdict or any other mental illness defense. The State asks this Court to adopt a
per se
rule that a defense attorney is prohibited from advancing a mental illness defense in the guilt phase if the defendant is opposed to that approach. Neither the State, nor the attorneys for Cooke, nor the trial judge’s attorneys
1
were able to find a prior case from any jurisdiction deciding that exact issue.
In this expedited matter, we announced our decision yesterday because the defense was scheduled to begin today in the guilt phase of the ongoing capital murder trial.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit