Supreme Court of Missouri February 27, 2007, SC 87921 (State v. Banks)

Also known as

United States · · · 27-02-2007

PER CURIAM

1

A jury found Jeremy L. Banks guilty of first-degree murder and armed criminal action for killing Alvon Turner on September 14, 2008, in Kansas City. Banks does not challenge the sufficiency of the state’s evidence against him. He correctly claims the prosecuting attorney’s rebuttal closing argument referring to Banks as the “Devil” was improper and prejudicial. The judgment is reversed, and the case is remanded.

The Argument, Objection, and Ruling

In his closing argument, Banks argued to the jury that the witnesses to the shooting, which occurred at a “crack house,” were drug users, and he questioned their ability to perceive accurately. He noted that police detectives “weren’t there. They don’t know what happened.... It is logical that all the detectivefs] had is based on what people tell [them], outside of scientific evidence which they didn’t even try to get [in this] case. So the State’s ease hinges upon the believability of [the state’s witnesses at the scene].”

The prosecuting attorney responded in rebuttal:

[Police detectives] didn’t just go on the word of a crack addict. They had several witnesses.

And, ladies and gentlemen, when the scene is set and held

2

and we have to go and catch the Devil, there are no angels as witnesses. This is Hell. He is the Devil. They aren’t angels. He is guilty beyond a reasonable doubt.

Banks objected: “Calling my client a devil is improper argument that was intentional and calls for a mistrial.” The prosecutor responded that she was not name-calling: “It’s an analogy. I set up the analogy properly.” Banks retorted that “the analogy [is] improper when you say somebody is Satan.” The circuit court overruled Banks’ objection.

The Prosecutor’s Responsibility

The comment to Rule 4-8.8 provides:

A prosecutor has the responsibility of a minister of justice and not simply that of

*120

an advocate.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.