Court of Appeals of Arkansas January 24, 2007, CA 06-438 (Drummond v. Shepherd)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-01-2007

LarryD. Vaught, Judge.

Appellant Curtis Drummond argues that the trial court erred by dismissing his prescriptive-easement action and erroneously granting appellees’ motion for attorney’s fees. We affirm in part and reverse in part.

This case began in October 2004, when Drummond filed a complaint asserting a right-of-use easement (on a gravel drive) across appellees’ property. In response to his claim, appellees filed a 12(b)(6) motion to dismiss — arguing that Drummond had previously sought to have this same drive designated a roadway-by-necessity in county court. Appellees noted that the necessity action had been dismissed on March 4, 2004, after the court-appointed reviewers determined that Drummond did in fact have access to his property by other means. Appellees also moved the court for an award of attorney’s fees pursuant to Ark. Code Ann. § 16-22-309 (Repl. 1999), arguing that Drummond’s claim for a prescriptive easement was wholly without merit. The motions were denied, and the matter went to trial on November 15, 2005. At trial, appellees renewed their motion to dismiss and their motion for attorney’s fees, arguing that Drummond failed to present a justiciable issue. The court again denied their motions.

At trial, Drummond testified that in 2002 he purchased a forty-acre tract near the Bidville Community in northern Crawford County. He stated that he was born in 1935 and had lived in the area of the property from 1939 until 1949. He offered proof that he and his cousins had crossed over the property periodically from the 1930s through 1967. However, the only proof of actual continuous usage of a particular route was from the time of Drummond’s purchase of the neighboring property in 2002, until he ceased using the route in 2004. Specifically, Drummond testified that he had used the roadway “since I got it [the property in 2002] until about a year ago, whenever Ellison’s wife stopped me there and told me she didn’t want me going across her property no more.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.