Court of Appeals of Maryland June 21, 2007, 139, Sept. Term, 2005 (Getty v. Carroll County Board of Elections)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-06-2007

BELL, Chief Judge.

The instant case concerns the election of local public officials in the State of Maryland. Specifically, at the core of this action is the issue of the authority of the Circuit Court for Carroll County, by its approval of an agreement (“Consent Order”) between a private party and an executive agency, to modify the method of election of Carroll County commissioners.

1

Article VII of the Maryland Constitution, captioned “Sundry Officers,” governs the method of election of commissioners in a county commissioner form of local government. It provides:

“Section 1. The County Commissioners of each county not governed by Article XI-A of this Constitution.[

2

] may be elected by the voters of

commissioner districts established

*714

therein,

or by the voters

of the entire county [at-large],

or by a combination of these methods of election,

as provided by the General Assembly by

law.”

“Section 2. The number, compensation, and powers and duties of the County Commissioners of each county not governed by Article XI-A of this Constitution shall

be such as now are or may be hereafter prescribed by law.”

(Emphasis added). Because we conclude that, as ordained by the Constitution, the power and authority to designate the method of election ultimately, and exclusively, lies with the Legislature, we shall hold that the Circuit Court’s approval of the Consent Order authorizing a change in the method of election of county commissioners was a clear violation of Article VII, §§ 1 and 2 of the Maryland Constitution.

I.

In the case sub

judice,

the Carroll County Board of Elections (“the Board”), in an attempt to expand the number of county commissioners in order to implement district, instead of at-large, representation, entered into a Consent Order with Dana Lee Dembrow (“Dembrow”), a registered voter in Carroll County, Maryland.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.