Supreme Judicial Court of Maine July 5, 2007 (NORTH SEBAGO SHORES, LLC v. Mazzaglia)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-07-2007

MEAD, J.

[¶ 1] North Sebago Shores, LLC

1

(NSS) appeals a judgment of the Superior Court (Cumberland County,

Cole, J.)

granting the Mazzaglia Family Trust’s motion for a summary judgment on all three counts of a complaint filed by NSS. The NSS complaint sought a declaratory judgment that a swim line erected by Mazzaglia interfered with its easement rights to an area known as Third Beach, an injunction prohibiting Mazzaglia from interfering with its easement rights in the future, and damages for trespass and nuisance. NSS contends that the trial court erred in its construction of the easement, which it argues is ambiguous.

2

[¶ 2] The Trust cross-appeals the judgment of the trial court, arguing that although the trial court properly granted its motion for a summary judgment on NSS’s complaint, it interpreted the scope of the easement too broadly. In addition, the Trust contends that the trial court erred in denying its motion for a summary judgment on the Trust’s counterclaim against NSS for trespass and nuisance.

[¶ 3] We affirm the trial court’s judgment granting the Trust’s motion for a summary judgment on NSS’s complaint, concluding that the language of the easement is unambiguous. We vacate, however, the trial court’s judgment regarding the Trust’s counterclaim for a declaratory judgment seeking to limit the scope of NSS’s easement rights. We likewise vacate the trial court’s final order denying the Trust’s motion for a partial summary judgment on its counterclaim for trespass and nuisance on the grounds that the order is interlocutory and not a final judgment, and that trespass and nuisance are issues of fact that require an evidentiary hearing before the court.

I. BACKGROUND

[¶ 4] In 1987, the Patten Development Corporation of Maine created a residential subdivision on the shores of Lake Sebago in Naples known as Lake Sebago Estates.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.