Commonwealth Court of Pennsylvania January 9, 2007 (City of Wilkes-Barre v. Urban)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-01-2007

*1231

OPINION BY

Judge FRIEDMAN.

Denise Carey (Carey) appeals from that portion of the November 15, 2005, order of the Court of Common Pleas of Luzerne County (trial court) awarding $11,056 in attorney’s fees and costs to the City of Wilkes-Barre (City). We reverse.

Unhappy with the City’s closing of a neighborhood fire house, Carey filed a Petition to Amend Provisions of the City’s Home Rule Charter (Petition) on August 5, 2005. Through the Petition, Carey sought to create an initiative and referendum procedure for City residents. (S.R.R., Exhibit A.) On August 16, 2005, the City filed formal objections and a motion to set aside the Petition, pursuant to section 977 of the Pennsylvania Election Code (Code).

1

In its motion to set aside the Petition, the City averred that Carey’s proposed amendments conflicted with specific provisions of the City’s Home Rule Charter and violated the Pennsylvania' Home Rule Charter and Optional Plans Law,

2

the Pennsylvania Constitution and the Code. With respect to the Code, the City alleged that circulators induced signors to sign the Petition by falsely representing that it was a petition to reopen the closed fire house. The City also alleged,

inter alia,

that a number of the signors were not registered voters, that some names were crossed out and that a number of people wrote only “W-B” instead of spelling out the full name of the City as required by law.

3

(S.R.R. at 3-11.)

The trial court scheduled a hearing on the City’s objections for Wednesday, August 24, 2005. Present at the hearing were counsel for the Luzerne County Board of Elections (Elections Board), Elections Board member Stephen Urban, counsel for the City, Carey and her counsel. Carey was sworn in and, in response to the trial court’s questions, confirmed that she wished to withdraw her Petition.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.