Michigan Court of Appeals September 28, 2007, Docket 264029, 264091 (Braverman v. Garden City Hospital)

Per CURIAM.

Pursuant to MCR 7.215(J), this Court convened a special panel to resolve the conflict between

*707

the opinions in

Braverman v Garden City Hosp,

272 Mich App 72; 724 NW2d 285 (2006)

(Braverman I),

vacated in part 272 Mich App 801 (2006),

1

and

Verbrugghe v Select Specialty Hosp-Macomb Co, Inc,

270 Mich App 383; 715 NW2d 72 (2006), application for leave to appeal held in abeyance