Supreme Court of Connecticut May 15, 2007, SC 17717 (A & M Towing & Recovery, Inc. v. Guay)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-05-2007

Opinion

KATZ, J.

In this action for unpaid rent under a lease of commercial premises and other relief, the defendants, Bernard Guay and Bemie’s Repair Service, LLC (Bernie’s), appeal from the judgment of the trial court rendered in favor of the plaintiff, A and M Towing and Recovery, Inc. The defendants’ principal claim on appeal is that the trial court improperly awarded damages to the plaintiff for unpaid rent despite the plaintiffs failure to have a certificate of occupancy for the property, as required under General Statutes § 29-265 (a),

1

during the defendants’ occupancy. The defendants essentially contend that the plaintiffs failure to obtain the certificate of occupancy was unlawful and in contravention to the public policy of protecting public safety underlying the requirement for obtaining such certification and, therefore, should preclude it from recovering under the lease. We affirm the trial court’s judgment.

The trial court found the following facts that are uncontested on appeal to this court. The plaintiff has owned the subject property, located at 422 Tolland Street in the town of East Hartford (town), since at least 1983. The plaintiff applied for a certificate of occupancy for the premises, but did not receive one, despite

*437

efforts that continued after the defendants’ occupancy of the premises began. In early 2003, the parties entered into an oral agreement for a month-to-month lease of the premises for $800 per month. The defendants planned to operate a towing and motor vehicle repair business on the premises. The plaintiff did not inform the defendants that there was no certificate of occupancy for the premises. The defendants took possession in March, 2003, and, a few days later, discovered that there was no certificate of occupancy when Guay went to the town hall to apply for a business license. The defendants thereafter informed the plaintiff that they intended to vacate the premises.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.