Court of Special Appeals of Maryland May 24, 2007, 0583 September Term, 2006 (Jacksonville MacHine and Repair, Inc. v. Kent Sand and Gravel, LLC)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-05-2007

ADKINS, J.

This appeal challenges a ruling by the Circuit Court for Kent County that a dredge erected by appellant Jacksonville Machine and Repair, Inc. (“Jacksonville Machine”) inside a quarry operated by appellee Kent Sand and Gravel, LLC is

*4

not subject to a mechanic’s lien because it is not a “machine” within the meaning of McLCode (1974, 2003 Repl.Vol., 2006 Cum.Supp.), section 9-102(c) of the Real Property Article (RP). We shall hold that the dredge may be a lienable machine, although we do not decide on this incomplete record whether a lien is warranted in this instance.

FACTS AND LEGAL PROCEEDINGS

Kent Sand and Gravel contracted with George Waldreck of Jacksonville, Florida, for the construction and installation of a “70' x 28' x 5"” dredge at an enclosed gravel quarry in Galena, which is leased by Kent Sand and Gravel. In turn, Waldreck subcontracted with Jacksonville Machine, also of Jacksonville, Florida, for construction services and materials to install and repair the dredge.

1

Waldreck allegedly failed to pay Jacksonville Machine for invoiced materials and work performed on site from May 16 through September 20, 2005. Jacksonville Machine served Kent Sand and Gravel with notice of its intent to seek a mechanic’s lien. Waldreck died shortly thereafter.

In February 2006, Jacksonville Machine filed a complaint to establish a $119, 799. 68 mechanic’s lien against the dredge under RP section 9-102(c). The Circuit Court for Kent County issued a show cause order. At the conclusion of the show cause hearing, the circuit court dismissed Jacksonville Machine’s complaint. This timely appeal followed.

DISCUSSION

Standard Of Review

In

Gravett v. Covenant Life Church,

154 Md.App. 640, 645, 841 A.2d 342 (2004), we set forth the standard by which we review the dismissal of a mechanic’s lien complaint:

*5

“The proper standard for reviewing the grant of a motion to dismiss is whether the trial court was legally correct.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.