Superior Court of Pennsylvania October 11, 2007 (McNeil v. Jordan)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-10-2007
OPINION BY
COLVILLE, J.:
¶ 1 This case is an appeal from the trial court’s order that (1) denied Appellant’s motion to permit discovery in aid of the preparation of an amended complaint and (2) dismissed the case because the complaint was legally insufficient to state a cause of action. We affirm.
Facts
1
¶ 2 Appellant’s father amassed a sizeable fortune. Upon his demise, his estate funded a marital trust for the lifetime benefit of his wife, Appellant’s mother. Under the testamentary scheme set forth by Appellant’s father, the marital trust proceeds were, upon the eventual death of Appellant’s mother, to be placed in separate trusts for the couple’s children, excluding Appellant. However, Appellant’s father had given his wife a general power of appointment permitting her to modify the aforesaid testamentary scheme. This power included,
inter alia,
the right to alter the father’s directions that excluded Appellant from the marital trust distribution. Thus, Appellant’s mother had the authority to include him in the ultimate distribution of the funds in her marital trust.
¶ 3 Appellant’s mother exercised the power of appointment to some extent, making bequests to various people and/or groups, including Appellant. However, a substantial amount of the marital trust remained therein. Upon her death in
*741
1998, the remainder passed equally to Appellant’s siblings while he was excluded.
¶ 4 Thereafter, Appellant sued Appellees (Appellant’s sister and her husband), alleging they had tortiously interfered with his testamentary expectancy. The elements of that tort are: (1) the testator indicated an intent to change his or her will to provide a described benefit for the plaintiff; (2) the defendant used fraud, misrepresentation or undue influence to prevent the execution of the intended will; (8) the defendant successfully prevented that execution; and (4) but for the defendant’s conduct, the testator would have changed the will.
McNeil,
894 A.2d at 1268,1264 n. 3.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit