District Court, C.D. California February 5, 2007, CV 04-7078GPSSSX (Palm Desert National Bank v. Federal Insurance)

Also known as

United States · · · 05-02-2007

ORDER DENYING PALM DESERT’S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND GRANTING FEDERAL’S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT

SCHIAVELLI, District Judge.

This case comes before the Court on Plaintiff Palm Desert National Bank (“PDNB”) and Defendant Federal Insurance Company’s (“Federal”) motions for partial summary judgment and summary judgment, respectively. The parties have filed a stipulation of undisputed facts

*1045

(“Joint Stip”), which both parties admit forms the core of the facts necessary to resolve the cross-motions.

I. BACKGROUND

PDNB is a bank, headquartered in Palm Desert, California, that engages in the business of supplying “vault cash” to automated teller machines (“ATMs” or “ACMs”) throughout the country. Federal is an insurance company that contracted (in the form of a financial institution bond) with PDNB to insure it against certain losses associated with this business. PDNB made the claim of loss involved here when it discovered that the armored car company that serviced its various ATMs, Tri-State Armored Services, Inc. (“Tri-State”) had stolen approximately $50 million dollars. Because the process involved in servicing ATMs are critical to resolving the issues of contractual interpretation raised in these cross-motions, that process is set out in detail below.

In order to provide vault cash to the various ATMs it serviced in Pennsylvania, PDNB contracted with Tri-State to transport money to and ¡from the ATMs and performed other balancing, settlement and maintenance services relating to the ATMs. (Joint Stip. at ¶ 3.) When an ATM needed more cash, third party ATM owners would advise PDNB, and PDNB would wire the required funds to its correspondent bank in the area, First Union National Bank (“First Union”).

(Id.,

¶ 5.) PDNB also would fax or e-mail Tri-State written instructions specifying which ATMs needed cash and in what amounts, and TriState accordingly would send an armored vehicle to First Union to retrieve the vault cash.

(Id.,

¶ 6.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.