Colorado Court of Appeals April 26, 2007, 03CA1364 (People v. Prentiss)
Also known as
United States · · · 26-04-2007
Opinion by
Judge ROTHENBERG.
In summary, we conclude the trial court erred in ruling as a Opinion is Modified to read:
In his Petition for Rehearing, defendant contends we have erred "by requiring the defense to make an offer of proof even with respect to relevant evidence under § 18-3-407(1)(b)." According to him, the opinion is incorrect because it "effectively holds that the Rape Shield's procedural requirements for presumptively irrelevant evidence apply even to relevant evidence." We disagree. Defendant's argument, if accepted, would mean that whenever an accused in a sexual assault case proffers evidence that falls outside the three statutory exceptions in the Rape Shield statute, that evidence is presumed to be admissible, and that in such case, there is no requirement that the court determine whether the evidence is relevant to the particular case involved, whether its probative value outweighs any unfair prejudice, or whether the defense is engaging in a "fishing expedition" based upon speculation. We conclude defendant reads the Rape Shield statute too narrowly.
In McKenna, supra, 196 Colo. at 371-72, 585 P.2d at 277-78, the supreme court discussed the public policy underlying the statute:
Prior to the enactment of this statute, defense counsel in a rape case was accorded wide latitude in cross-examining the prosecutrix. Since her credibility was placed in issue when she testified, her pri- or sexual conduct was considered admissible to undermine her credibility,. Moreover, where consent was a defense, as it frequently was, it was thought that the fact that she had consented to sexual relations with others on other occasions might justify a factfinder in concluding that she prob
*920
ably had consented to the sexual act giving rise to the prosecution.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit