Court of Appeals of Washington June 4, 2007, 58680-7-I (In Re Hubert)

Also known as

United States · · · 04-06-2007

158 P.3d 1282 (2007) In the Matter of the Personal Restraint Petition of Nicolas HUBERT, Petitioner. No. 58680-7-I. Court of Appeals of Washington, Division 1. June 4, 2007. *1283 David Allen, Allen Hansen & Maybrown, Seattle, for Appellants. David McEachran, Whatcom County Prosecutor's Office, Bellingham, for Respondents. ELLINGTON, J. ¶ 1 Where counsel in a criminal case fails to advance a defense authorized by statute, and there is evidence to support the defense, counsel's performance is deficient. Here, that deficient performance prejudiced Nicolas Hubert. We grant his personal restraint petition, vacate the conviction, and remand for a new trial. BACKGROUND ¶ 2 On May 15, 2004, Noel Wood joined her roommate Sandy Sallee and their friend Jenny Hale for a "girls' night out," drinking and dancing at several bars in Bellingham. Towards the end of the evening, the women met Nicolas Hubert, who joined them at a table. As the group left the bar, Sallee invited Hubert to return to the house she shared with Wood for another drink. Sallee and Hubert drove to the house together. Hale drove Wood home and dropped her off, but did not come in. ¶ 3 At the house, Wood shared a beer with Hubert and Sallee. At trial, she testified that she may also have smoked marijuana with them. She grew tired and retreated to her bedroom, telling both Sallee and Hubert that she was tired and going to sleep. Eventually, Sallee also went to bed, and invited Hubert to sleep on their couch rather than drive home. ¶ 4 In the early morning hours, Hubert entered Wood's bedroom and initiated a sexual encounter. Their accounts of this event differ greatly, but are not wholly inconsistent. ¶ 5 Hubert testified that Wood was friendly and flirtatious with him throughout the evening and seemed receptive to a sexual relationship. He testified he knocked, entered the bedroom, and lay down beside Wood in bed. Wood rolled over and said "Hi Neeco," using the nickname by which Hubert had introduced himself.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.