Court of Appeals of Utah July 12, 2007, 20060712-CA (Crowley v. Black)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-07-2007
OPINION
BENCH, Presiding Judge:
1 Plaintiff John K. Crowley contests the trial court's ruling that prejudgment interest and attorney fees should not be included as part of Plaintiffs award. We reverse and remand.
BACKGROUND
T2 In July 1996, Defendant Chris Black entered into a lease for a house owned by Plaintiff and located in Sandy, Utah. In June 1997, Defendant entered into a second, substitute lease for the same house. The agreement for the second lease included the following provision for attorney fees:
In the event that the Owner shall prevail in any legal action brought by either party to enforce the terms hereof or relating to the demised premises, Owner shall be entitled to all costs incurred in connection with
*1089
such action, including a reasonable attorney fee.
T3 In December 2001, Defendant terminated his lease and moved out of the house.
1
Plaintiff commenced this action in September 2002 to recover damages for lost rent and the cost of repairs incurred in connection with Defendant's breach of the lease. Plaintiff's complaint requested $5538.76 for repair costs and $1281.25 for lost rent. Plaintiff estimated $1500 for court costs and attorney fees. Defendant denied owing any money to Plaintiff. The trial court found that the house sustained abnormally high wear and tear during Defendant's lease. The trial court held that Plaintiff was entitled to $4141.76 in damages for the cost of repairs. The court also awarded $1462.50 in damages for lost rent, but credited Defendant with $925 for his security deposit In total, the court awarded $4679.26 in damages to Plaintiff.
T 4 At the end of trial, the court stated that "[Plaintiff] certainly did not prevail to the total amount" requested. Thus, the court found that there was no prevailing party and declined to grant attorney fees. The court did, however, award Plaintiff $327.80 for court costs.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit