Texas Court of Appeals, 4th District (San Antonio) October 24, 2007, 04-05-00834-CR (Robert Walter Fischer v. State)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-10-2007

DISSENTING OPINION No. 04-05-00834-CR Robert Walter FISCHER, Appellant v. The STATE of Texas, Appellee From the 226th Judicial District Court, Bexar County, Texas Trial Court No. 2004-CR-0216 Honorable Sid L. Harle, Judge Presiding Opinion by: Rebecca Simmons, Justice Dissenting opinion by: Phylis J. Speedlin, Justice Sitting: Sandee Bryan Marion, Justice Phylis J. Speedlin, Justice Rebecca Simmons, Justice Delivered and Filed: October 24, 2007 The dissenting opinion issued on September 5, 2007 is withdrawn and this dissenting opinion is substituted to respond to the modifications made to the majority opinion. I disagree with the majority's conclusion that the trial court's admission of the extraneous offense evidence, i.e., the rifle theft, during the guilt/innocence phase was error. As noted by the majority, Fischer only challenges "the question of threshold admissibility" that the trial court made under Rule 104(b). Tex. R. Evid. 104(b). Specifically, Fischer maintains the trial court should not have admitted evidence of the rifle theft because "no reasonable fact finder" could conclude beyond a reasonable doubt that Fischer had stolen the missing Cricket rifle from the Wal-Mart at which he worked based solely on the State's proffer. In 1994, our Court of Criminal Appeals held that before a trial court could admit evidence of an extraneous offense during the guilt/innocence phase of trial, "the trial court must, under rule 104(b), make an initial determination at the proffer of the evidence, that a jury could reasonably find beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant committed the extraneous offense." Harrell v. State, 884 S.W.2d 154, 160 (Tex. Crim. App. 1994) (stating that "the proper quantum of proof" to be used by the trial court in determining the admissibility of extraneous offense evidence is the same as that used by the jury - i.e., beyond a reasonable doubt, rather than a "clear showing" or a preponderance of the evidence).

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.