Kentucky Supreme Court November 21, 2007, 2007 SC 000324 (Appalachian Regional Healthcare, Inc. v. Hon Eddy Coleman Judge, Circuit Court)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-11-2007

RENDERED : NOVEMBER 21, 2007

TO BE PUBLISHED

,*uPrmt daurf of rufurkg

2007-SC-000324-MR

APPALACHIAN REGIONAL HEALTHCARE, INC . APPELLANT

ON APPEAL FROM COURT OF APPEALS

V. CASE NUMBER 2007-CA-000092

PIKE CIRCUIT COURT NO. 06-CI-001096

HONORABLE EDDY COLEMAN, JUDGE,

CIRCUIT COURT

AND

THE ESTATE OF PAUL CONNER BREWER, BY AND

THROUGH SHAWN BAKER, ADMINISTRATRIX ;

AND SHAWN BAKER, INDIVIDUALLY

(REAL PARTIES IN INTEREST) APPELLEES

OPINION OF THE COURT BY JUSTICE NOBLE

REVERSING

This matter is before the Court on the Court of Appeals's denial of a petition for a

writ of prohibition . Appellant, Appalachian Regional Healthcare, Inc., sought the writ to

bar the circuit judge, who had recused himself from the case, from further participating

in the matter, including hearing a motion to reconsider his recusal order . The Court of

Appeals applied the wrong standard, and failed to address whether the trial judge was

proceeding or about to proceed outside his jurisdiction . Because the action Judge

Coleman has proposed to take exceeds his jurisdiction, and a writ is an appropriate

means of limiting his action to within his jurisdiction, the Court of Appeals erred by not

granting the requested writ.

1. Background

The underlying case involves claims of medical negligence and fraud brought

against Appellant in Pike Circuit Court by Shawn Baker, both individually and in her

representative capacity on behalf of the estate of her deceased child. It was originally

assigned to Division II of the circuit court to be heard by Judge Steven Combs. At a

hearing on a motion to dismiss or change venue in November 2006, Judge Combs

recused himself from the case under KRS 26A.01 5(2)(d)(1) because his sister-in-law

was the Secretary-Treasurer and a trustee for Appellant . He transferred the case to the

other division of the Pike Circuit Court where it was to be heard by Judge Eddy

Coleman .

Judge Coleman set the case for a hearing on the motion to dismiss or change

venue on December 15, 2006.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.